Pack and Play Vs. Crib: Which Is Better for Baby?

  1. Home
  2. Playpen
  3. Pack and Play Vs. Crib: Which Is Better for Baby?

Table of Contents

Newborn Travel Multifunction Playpen

Pack ‘n plays and cribs are products parents often consider when choosing a place for their baby to sleep. These two products serve similar purposes but come with distinct features and considerations that parents should weigh carefully. This article delves into the specifics of pack ‘n plays and cribs in an effort to provide comprehensive insight to help parents make an informed decision.

What Is Pack and Play?

Pack ‘n plays, also known as playards, are versatile, portable units that offer a safe space for babies and toddlers to sleep and play. It typically consists of a sturdy frame made of metal or plastic, surrounded by mesh sides for breathability and visibility. The Pack and Play often comes with a mattress pad for comfort and can be easily folded up for travel or storage, making it a popular choice for families on the go.

Initially designed for easy transport and storage, these units have evolved significantly. Nowadays, many pack ‘n plays come equipped with features such as bassinets, changing stations, and mobiles, enhancing their functionality beyond a simple play area.

What Is a Crib?

Baby Cribs, on the other hand, are stationary pieces of furniture designed specifically for sleeping. It typically features sturdy construction with slatted sides and a solid frame to ensure safety.  Unlike pack ‘n plays, cribs are usually larger and more stationary which are not designed for easy mobility. It remains in one place, typically in the baby’s nursery.

What Is the Difference Between Crib and Pack ‘n Play

Primary Function

Crib: Cribs are stationary, durable, and designed solely for sleep, offering a long-term solution that can potentially serve a child for several years. 

Pack ‘n Play: A pack ‘n play, on the other hand, is a versatile product that serves dual purposes, designed for both sleep and play.

Design and Construction

Crib: It typically features a sturdy and fixed structure with slatted sides and a solid frame. They’re larger in size.

Pack ‘n Play: It has a collapsible frame made of metal or plastic, with mesh sides for breathability. It often comes with a removable mattress pad for sleeping and can be easily folded up.


Crib: Cribs are stationary and not designed for frequent movement. Once assembled, they remain in place within a nursery.

Pack ‘n Play: pack ‘n plays are explicitly designed for portability. They can be easily folded and transported, making them ideal for travel, visits to relatives, or temporary sleep arrangements in different rooms of the house.


Crib: Cribs are primarily for sleeping, and their design reflects this. While some cribs may offer convertible features to transform into toddler beds or daybeds, their primary function remains as a sleeping space.

Pack ‘n Play: pack ‘n plays are versatile, serving not only as a portable crib but also as a playpen during waking hours. 

Service Life

Crib: Cribs are typically designed for long-term use, accommodating a child from infancy through toddlerhood and sometimes beyond. A well-constructed crib made from high-quality materials can withstand years of use, potentially lasting through multiple children if properly maintained.

Pack ‘n Play: A pack ‘n play is generally used only during the early years of a child’s life, up until they outgrow the weight or height limits, which typically occurs around toddler age. Moreover, the collapsible nature of pack ‘n plays makes them susceptible to wear and tear, especially if frequently transported or folded and unfolded.

Pros and Cons of Pack ‘n Play


1. Portability: The most significant advantage of a pack ‘n play is its portability. It can be easily folded and transported, making it ideal for travel, visiting relatives, or overnight stays away from home.

2. Versatility: With features like bassinets and changing stations, it serves multiple functions beyond providing a safe play area.

3. Space-saving: Unlike traditional baby beds, pack ‘n plays are compact and take up less space, making them suitable for small apartments, shared bedrooms, or temporary living arrangements.

4. Ease of Assembly: Most pack ‘n plays are designed for quick and straightforward assembly, with no tools required. This convenience is especially valuable when setting up a temporary sleep or play area on the go.

5. Affordability: Pack ‘n plays are often more affordable than cribs, making them a budget-friendly option for families looking to save money on baby gear.


1. Durability: It may not offer the same level of durability as a stationary crib. They may become less practical as a child grows older and requires more space

2. Less Comfortable Mattress: The mattresses in pack ‘n plays are typically thinner and less supportive than crib mattresses, which might affect sleep quality, especially over extended periods.

3. Less Sturdy Construction: Pack ‘n plays are designed to be lightweight and portable, which may result in a less sturdy construction compared to cribs.

4. Aesthetic Appeal: Most pack ‘n plays have a functional design that may not match the aesthetic preferences of some parents.

Pros and Cons of Crib


1. Safety and Stability: Cribs are usually made of solid wood and have a solid structure. They typically feature fixed sides, slatted designs for airflow, and non-toxic finishes, providing peace of mind to parents regarding their child’s safety during sleep.

2. Longevity: Cribs are designed for long-term use, accommodating a child from infancy through toddlerhood and sometimes beyond. 

3. Comfortable Mattress: Cribs usually come with a comfortable and supportive mattress designed specifically for infant sleep. 

4. Design Variety: Cribs come in numerous styles and finishes, allowing parents to choose one that fits their nursery’s decor perfectly.

5. Adjustable Mattress Height: Many cribs offer adjustable mattress heights, allowing parents to lower the mattress as the child grows and becomes more mobile. This feature helps prevent accidents such as falls as the baby learns to stand and climb.

6. Convertible Features: Many cribs offer convertible options, allowing them to transition into toddler beds, daybeds, or even full-size beds with the use of conversion kits. 


1. Immobility: Once assembled, the crib remains in place within a nursery or designated sleeping area, limiting flexibility for families who travel frequently or require temporary sleep arrangements in different rooms.

2. Cost: High-quality cribs can be a significant investment, especially when considering the additional cost of a crib mattress and bedding.

3. Size: Cribs take up more space than pack ‘n plays, which could be problematic in smaller homes or apartments.

4. Assembly and Disassembly: Crib’s initial assembly process can be time-consuming and may require tools. Disassembly for storage or transport can also be cumbersome, especially for larger or more intricate crib designs.

Can Baby Sleep in Pack ‘n Play Instead of a Crib

Yes, a baby can sleep in a pack ‘n play instead of a crib, provided the pack ‘n play meets safety standards and is used as directed. Many parents choose a pack ‘n play for its portability and versatility, especially in the early months when the baby may sleep in the same room as them. When opting for a pack ‘n play as a primary sleep environment, it’s crucial to ensure that the mattress is flat, firm, and free of any soft bedding, toys, or bumpers that could pose a risk of suffocation or sudden infant death syndrome.

Which Is Safer for Newborns, Pack ‘n Play or Crib?

Both pack ‘n plays and cribs can be safe for newborns, as long as they adhere to current safety standards set by regulatory bodies such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) in the United States. But no matter which product is used, the product must comply with safety standards and extra attention must be paid to safety when using it.

Key safety considerations for both pack ‘n plays and cribs include:

Firm Mattress: The sleeping surface should be firm to reduce the risk of suffocation and ensure proper support for the baby’s developing body.

Tight-Fitting Sheets: Sheets should fit snugly around the mattress to prevent any bunching or loosening that could pose an entrapment hazard.

Absence of Loose Bedding or Soft Toys: Avoid placing loose blankets, pillows, or soft toys in the sleeping area, as these items can increase the risk of suffocation or strangulation.

Follow Manufacturer’s Guidelines: Always adhere to the manufacturer’s instructions for assembly, use, and maintenance of the product. 

Check for Recalls: Regularly check for any recalls or safety alerts issued for the specific model of pack ‘n play or crib you’re using. 

Additionally, when using a pack ‘n play with a bassinet attachment for newborns, ensure that the bassinet is securely attached and that your baby is placed in the recommended sleeping position. As your baby grows and becomes more mobile, transition to the lower mattress setting provided in the pack ‘n play or move them to a crib with appropriate safety modifications.

Types of Pack ‘n Play

Basic Pack and Play

The basic pack and play stands as the entry-level model in the world of portable playards, designed with simplicity and portability in mind. Lacking the bells and whistles of more advanced models, the Basic Pack and Play offers a straightforward, compact, and easily transportable play solution for parents on the move.

This is a standard model with a simple design, a sturdy frame, and a baby play area. It usually includes a comfortable mattress without many extra features. 

Pack and Play with the Bassinet

Elevating the functionality of the basic pack and play, models equipped with a bassinet feature provide a dedicated sleeping space suited for newborns. This variation of the traditional playard combines the functionality of a playpen with the added convenience of a removable bassinet. At its essence, the pack ‘n play with Bassinet maintains the sturdy frame and spacious play area characteristic of standard playards. However, it elevates the design by incorporating a bassinet attachment. The removable bassinet offers a snug and cozy environment that mimics the womb, promoting better sleep during the early months of a baby’s life.

During the early months, when babies require frequent feedings and diaper changes, having the bassinet within arm’s reach can streamline caregiving tasks, especially during nighttime. As the baby grows, the bassinet can be easily removed, allowing the playard to transition into a standard play area suitable for playtime and exploration.

Twin Pack and Play

Twin Pack and Play
(Source: Amazon)

For families blessed with twins, the twin pack and play offers a practical solution to accommodate two infants simultaneously. This model retains the sturdy frame and spacious play area characteristic of standard playards. However, it enhances the design by incorporating two distinct sleep spaces, each equipped with its own bassinet or sleep surface. This allows parents to create individualized sleeping environments for each baby while still keeping them within proximity for monitoring and caregiving.

Furthermore, the twin pack ‘n play often features a shared play area between the two sleep spaces, providing ample room for both babies to engage in playtime and exploration. This fosters social interaction and bonding between siblings while encouraging developmental milestones such as crawling, rolling, and reaching.

Pack and Play with Changing Table

Adding another layer of convenience, some pack and play models include a changing table attachment, transforming the unit into an all-in-one care station. This feature allows parents to change diapers quickly and comfortably without leaving the baby’s side, ensuring everything they need is within arm’s reach. 

This integrated changing table typically attaches securely to the top rails of the playard, providing a stable and secure platform for diaper changes. Furthermore, the changing table is designed with convenience and ease of use in mind. It often features a wipe-clean surface that is easy to sanitize, ensuring a hygienic environment for diaper changes. Many models also include storage compartments or organizers, providing convenient access to diapers, wipes, and other diapering essentials.

Pack ‘n Play with Canopy

For families who enjoy spending time outdoors, the pack ‘n play with canopy provides a safe and shaded environment for babies to play and rest. The canopy offers protection from the sun’s harmful rays, ensuring the baby remains cool and comfortable during outdoor activities. 

One of the key benefits of the pack ‘n play with canopy is its versatility. Whether you’re spending a day at the park, enjoying a picnic in the backyard, or attending an outdoor event, this playard provides a convenient and portable solution for keeping your baby protected from the sun. The canopy can be easily adjusted to provide the desired amount of shade, allowing your little one to enjoy outdoor playtime while staying cool and comfortable.

Types of Crib

Mini Crib

Mini cribs are a compact version of standard cribs, designed to fit smaller spaces without sacrificing the comfort or safety of the baby. They are an excellent option for parents with limited living space or for those who prefer a crib that can be easily moved from one room to another. Despite their smaller size, mini cribs still offer adjustable mattress heights and are subject to the same safety standards as full-sized cribs. They typically feature a sturdy frame with four fixed sides, ensuring stability and security. 

Bedside Crib

Bedside cribs, also known as co-sleepers, are designed to be placed next to the parents’ bed, offering a safe way to keep the baby close during the night. These cribs often feature a retractable side that allows parents easy access to the baby, making nighttime feedings and comforting more convenient. This close proximity makes nighttime feedings more convenient and less disruptive, as parents can quickly attend to their baby’s needs without having to leave their own bed.

While bedside cribs provide proximity for nighttime care, they also maintain a separate sleep surface for the baby, reducing the risk of accidental suffocation or overheating associated with bed-sharing.

Convertible Crib

A convertible crib is a versatile and long-term investment in your child’s sleep space. Unlike traditional cribs that are designed for infants and must eventually be replaced with a toddler or twin bed, convertible cribs are designed to adapt and grow with your child. Investing in a convertible crib offers long-term value by eliminating the need to purchase multiple beds as your child transitions from infancy to childhood. 

Common conversion options include transitioning from a crib to a toddler bed, then to a daybed, and finally to a full-size bed. Some models may offer additional configurations or accessories, such as a headboard and footboard for the full-size bed.

Folding Crib

Folding cribs offer the stability and safety of a traditional crib with the added benefit of foldability for storage or travel. These cribs are lightweight and compact when folded, making them easy to carry and transport in a car trunk, airplane, or luggage. 

While not as compact as Pack and Plays when folded, they provide a more familiar and comfortable sleeping environment for the baby when away from home. Folding cribs are ideal for grandparents’ houses or second homes where space might be limited.


Choosing between a pack and play and a crib depends on individual family needs, lifestyle, and space considerations. Pack and Plays offer portability and versatility, making them ideal for families on the go or those with limited space. Cribs, however, provide a stable, long-term sleep solution that can grow with the child.

Ultimately, the decision shouldn’t be about which is better universally, but rather which is better for your family’s specific situation. Assessing your family’s needs, lifestyle, and the space available will guide you to the right choice for your baby’s safe and comfortable sleep.

Recommended Related Articles:

Wonderful! Share this Case:

Get A Quote/Samples

*We respect your confidentiality and all information are protected.
error: Content is protected !!

Get a Quick Custom Quote
(for Business)

*We respect your confidentiality and all information are protected.